How to choose a song to work towards

There’s a song you always turn up in the car. You know every word, you love singing the verse, and when the chorus comes around, you quietly let the original singer take over.

Would that be a good song to work on?

It might be. The fact that you love it gives you a reason to practise. The question is whether there’s a way into the song that feels comfortable for your voice and gives you something specific you’d like to learn.

Here’s how I’d go about choosing.

1. Start with the moment you love

Think of two or three songs you’d happily come back to over the next few weeks. For each one, ask yourself: Is there a particular moment I’d love to sing?

Maybe it’s a line in the verse that feels like something you’d actually say. Maybe it’s the way the last chorus opens up. Or perhaps it’s a song you’d like to sing for someone you love.

Pay attention to your answer. “I’d love to sing that first verse as though I’m telling someone the story” already gives you an idea for your first practice session.

2. Try a verse and a chorus

It’s easy to choose a song based on the bit you know best. Before you decide, try a little of the verse, the chorus and, if it changes, the ending. You don’t need to sing the whole thing or test how high you can go. You’re getting a feel for where the melody sits in your voice.

Take that song from the car. Perhaps the verse feels conversational and easy, but the chorus sits high for several lines. That tells you more than simply asking, “Can I hit the highest note?” You might reach that note once and still find the rest of the chorus uncomfortable to sing.

If you have a backing track in a lower key, try it. Then go back and check the verse. Did the chorus become more comfortable? Can you still sing the lower lines clearly? The original artist’s key is a starting point. You’re allowed to find one that suits you.

3. Give the song one job

What would you like to get better at through this song?

Suppose you’ve found a key that feels comfortable, but something you loved about the verse disappears when you sing it. The words sound matter-of-fact, and you want them to feel affectionate. That’s a useful reason to choose the song. You have a phrase you care about and a quality you can explore, even before you’ve learnt the bridge.

Your goal could also be as simple as singing a familiar song all the way through while someone you trust listens. In that case, choosing a melody you already know well makes sense. Being heard is the part you want to practise.

4. Decide whether it’s the right song for now

A useful challenge is one you can name and begin to work on. If most of a song feels comfortable and there’s one section you’re curious about, you’ve probably found a good candidate.

If you’re chasing the notes, losing the words and trying to keep up with the phrasing all at once, it can be hard to tell what to practise first. And if you feel scratchiness or strain, don’t keep singing through it to prove you can finish. Set that version aside. You might explore a different arrangement with your teacher, work on just the verse, or save the song for later.

If you’re torn between two songs, finish this sentence for each one: “I want to work on this song because I’d love to feel more comfortable ______.” Choose the one that gives you a clear answer and makes you want to start singing.

Once you’ve chosen, my previous article, What should you actually practise to improve your singing?, walks you through what to do with that first phrase.

Have a song in mind? 🎶

Work towards singing it with weekly online group coaching and individual video feedback in Kickstart Your Singing Journey, my 12-week singing program.

Join the Kickstart waitlist

🎶 Give your singing a little direction

Kickstart Your Singing Journey

12 weeks of online group coaching to develop your voice, build confidence and work towards performing a song.

📅 Planned start: 22 February 2027

Get the details when enrolment opens. No commitment to enrol.

Next
Next

What should you actually practise to improve your singing?